Category: Metaphysics

  • The Argument from Contingency

    The Argument from Contingency
    ,

    Like many debates in philosophy, the dispute over the nature/existence of God has no clear answer. In this particular argument, the ball lies in the court of the theist, giving them the chance to create a logical argument deriving God as a conclusion from justifiable premises. There are many ways theists have done this. Some, Read more

  • Emergentism’s Explanatory Effectiveness

    Emergentism’s Explanatory Effectiveness

    What is emergentism? My answer is that it is a big word for a not-so-big concept. Emergentism is simply the idea that the sum is greater than the parts. The common example goes: But who cares about water. This idea can be applied to so many things, like the table you are leaning on or Read more

  • Pascal’s Wager

    Pascal’s Wager
    ,

    The French mathematician and philosopher Blaise Pascal had an argument about God. Unlike many of his predecessors, however, this argument was not one for God’s existence. It was an argument for why a rational person should believe in God. He called it Pascal’s Wager. The premises of the argument are simple. With these options, we Read more

  • Leibniz vs Spinoza vs Anthropic Principle: Why is our World Made the Way it is?

    Leibniz vs Spinoza vs Anthropic Principle: Why is our World Made the Way it is?

    I present in this article three conflicting views about how the world is made. Each view is plausible; however, some are more so than others. While Leibniz and Spinoza were 17th-century rationalists, the anthropic principle is relatively newer. As you can probably imagine, the older theories rely more on God/theology, while the anthropic principle is Read more

  • Problems with the Problem of Evil

    Problems with the Problem of Evil
    ,

    Disclaimer: I am Agnostic The problem of evil is one of, if not the, most famous arguments in philosophy of religion. It capitalizes on the common, Western understanding of God as a force that is omnipotent (all-powerful), omniscient (all-knowing), and omnibenevolent (all-good). If one accepts that their God embodies these three tenets, then the occurrence Read more

  • Plantinga’s Ontological Argument

    Plantinga’s Ontological Argument
    ,

    The ontological argument is often discarded as a relatively weak proof for the existence for God. While this is true, and some formulations such as Anselm’s can be immediately dismissed, stronger proofs do exist. Alvin Plantinga’s ontological argument is proof of this. Plantinga’s makes use of modality, or possibility, in conjunction with perfection to make Read more

  • Mind Comes First: Idealism and the Hard Problem of Consciousness

    Mind Comes First: Idealism and the Hard Problem of Consciousness

    “If a tree falls in the forest and no one is there to hear it, does it make a sound?” According to 18th century Irish philosopher George Berkeley, it most certainly does not. At first glance, idealism—or the concept that reality is made up of mind or consciousness—seems straight out of a fantasy book. In Read more

  • Comparison is the Thief of Joy: The World as Will (Schopenhauer)

    Comparison is the Thief of Joy: The World as Will (Schopenhauer)

    Like so many great thinkers, the German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer was largely unknown and unpopular. His greatest work, The World as Will and Representation, was developed as both a continuation and critique of the works of his predecessor, Immanuel Kant. If you haven’t already read my article on Kant’s Transcendental Idealism, it might be helpful Read more

  • Pneuma’s Panpsychism

    Pneuma’s Panpsychism

    Tool is an alternative metal band that I’ve loved since 8th grade. One of my favorite tracks by them (after “Jambi” and “Sober”) is “Pneuma”, an 11 minute and 53 second behemoth of a song. For some backstory, “Pneuma” is the second track off Tool’s fifth studio album Fear Inoculum—their first album since 2006.  A Read more

  • An Ontologically Parsimonious Argument for the Universe’s Inception

    An Ontologically Parsimonious Argument for the Universe’s Inception
    ,

    Intro As far as I can tell, the cosmological argument remains the sole most convincing argument for God’s existence. Whether in William Lane Craig’s Kalam or Leibniz’s contingency form, both pose God as the unmoved mover, a being whose existence is necessary in order for the universe to be explained. Both arguments also make some Read more

  • On Reason, Emergence, and Exploration: A Path Towards a Meaningful Life

    On Reason, Emergence, and Exploration: A Path Towards a Meaningful Life

    Exploration is our duty. Inside each of us is the astronomer staring up at the sky, pondering if celestial beings lay above. Inside each of us is the man on the frontier, slogging his wagon on its rusty axle across swamp and mountain, through sleet and desert. In the common day, these men are relics Read more

  • The Non-Identity Problem (Parfit, 2/2)

    The Non-Identity Problem (Parfit, 2/2)
    ,

    In yesterday’s post, I talked about the paradoxical non-identity problem, which leads to the absurd conclusion that some immoral actions, like purposely polluting the planet or attempting to give your child a horrible disease, actually cause little harm. In case you forgot, here is the standard layout of the argument: An action only harms a Read more

  • Philosopher of the Day: Boethius

    Philosopher of the Day: Boethius
    ,

    Boethius was a 6th-century Roman philosopher best known for his work The Consolation of Philosophy. Interestingly, Boethius wrote this work while in prison. He was imprisoned under the charge of treason by the Ostrogothic King Theodoric and was awaiting execution. His text was written with the purpose of finding intellectual and spiritual consolation in the Read more

  • Argument from Design (for God’s Existence)

    Argument from Design (for God’s Existence)
    ,

    Also known as the teleological argument, the argument from design is one of the most popular proofs for God’s existence. I’ll recount a version I saw on an instagram street interview. For background information, the street interview involved an atheist in a jacket and another man, a preacher, who attempted to prove God’s existence to Read more

  • What is Personal Identity? (2/2)

    What is Personal Identity? (2/2)

    This is the second part of a two-part series focused on personal-identity—what it is and how we can define it. In the first article, we recapped that identity cannot be tied to something merely physical, and therefore there must be some mental component that engages in the construction of the personal identity. We also covered, Read more

  • What is Personal Identity? (1/2)

    What is Personal Identity? (1/2)

    In this article, I’d like to talk about an interesting topic in contemporary philosophy. Let’s dive right in. Who are we? Some answers someone may throw out are: While descriptive, none of these answers prove sufficient for the question. I asked what we are, not how we relate to other people. We are only brothers Read more

  • Panpsychism: Close, but no Cigar (1/2)

    Panpsychism: Close, but no Cigar (1/2)

    As I covered yesterday, scientists and philosophers alike struggle broadly to define a conception of the relationships between consciousness and the world. Materialism, or the theory that mental processes arise from purely physical elements, has been widely critiqued. Likewise, mind-body dualism, similar to what Descartes radically proposed in the 17th century, deals with its own Read more

  • Cosmological Proof for God’s Existence (Descartes)

    Cosmological Proof for God’s Existence (Descartes)
    ,

    Descartes’ version of the Cosmological Argument is referred to as the stronger of his two arguments. There are countless different cosmological arguments for the existence of God, dating back to the ancient Greeks. Some types are still being debated today. What these arguments have in common is a reference to the principle of causality. It Read more

  • The Paradox of Akrasia, or Weakness of Will

    The Paradox of Akrasia, or Weakness of Will

    We all know the feeling. You have homework due the next day, but you’ve been binging Stranger Things on Netflix. You know that you have to complete your homework, and that there are tangible consequences if you don’t, yet you still decide to watch Stranger Things. Why? You seem to be acting irrationally, but you Read more

  • Determined to be Indeterminate: 3 problems with Determinism

    Determined to be Indeterminate: 3 problems with Determinism

    If you’re anything like me, the classic free will/determinism debate was the thing that drew you into philosophy. I wrote my first-ever philosophy paper about the debate, but I can’t read it now because it’s logically incoherent. However, I’m glad that I wrote that first paper. It provided a raw analysis of what my gut Read more

  • Russell’s Paradox (1/2)

    Russell’s Paradox (1/2)
    ,

    This spring, I wrote a research paper defending Mathematical Platonism, or the view that numbers exist outside of the mind. Numbers are abstract entities that exist in some non-mental and non-physical realm that we access through reason, not perception. A large part of my argument relied on the reductionist approach that math could be reduced Read more

  • Ontological Proof for God’s Existence (Descartes)

    Ontological Proof for God’s Existence (Descartes)
    ,

    After proving the existence of his mind, Descartes figures that the next logical thing to prove is the existence of God. He does this in two ways. I will explain one of them here, and then provide arguments against it. I’ll explain the other, much more complicated one later, when I better understand it. Descartes’ Read more

  • Mind Body Dualism (Descartes)

    Mind Body Dualism (Descartes)

    After proving with the Evil Demon thought experiment that his thoughts were the only things that he could be certain of, Descartes extrapolated the concept against the Monists. If Descartes could only be sure of the existence of his mind, how could his mind and body be one? It did not make sense, which led Read more

  • Boltzmann Brains & Simulation Theory

    Boltzmann Brains & Simulation Theory
    ,

    The ideas of Boltzmann Brains and Simulation Theory are interesting concepts that seem both logical and completely impractical at the same time. They’re funny brainteasers that, while impossible to disprove, can be thought about—and then discarded. Nonetheless, they’re worth sharing. Boltzmann Brains were a thought experiment proposed by Austrian physicist Ludwig Boltzmann. Before diving in, Read more

  • Philosophical Zombies: a Short Argument Against Physicalism

    Philosophical Zombies: a Short Argument Against Physicalism

    Physicalism is the somewhat outdated theory that everything we do or experience can be reduced down to physical components. The physicalist would believe that consciousness can be explained purely through physical matters. In other words, there is no mental component accompanying consciousness. An important term in the this discussion is what philosophers refer to as Read more

  • The Road Less Traveled: The Case for a Metaphysical Soul

    The Road Less Traveled: The Case for a Metaphysical Soul

    Two roads diverged in a wood, and I—  I took the one less traveled by And that has made all the difference Robert Frost, “The Road Not Taken” Intro Life is essentially a long string of decisions. We do not choose where we are born, what we look like, or how we are raised. Despite Read more

  • Kant’s Transcendental Idealism

    Kant’s Transcendental Idealism

    The Prussian Immanuel Kant was a groundbreaking philosopher. Kant’s metaphysics was monumental in that it provided system of thought that bridged the gap between the combating views of his time. Metaphysics-wise, my best interpretation of Kant’s transcendental idealism is that it mixed the views of the empiricists, who thought that the only perception of the Read more